Skip to main content
← All projects

Filtration Flow Rate vs Clarity

Engineer filters balancing flow speed against water clarity; introduce tradeoff thinking.

40 minMess: 3/5Engineering DesignMatter & Interactions

Safety notes

No ingestion. Wash hands after.

Step-by-step instructions

  1. Prepare dirty water: Mix flour with distilled water to create cloudy 'dirty water' in a clear cup.
  2. Design filter 1 - Fast flow: Build a filter using only gravel (large particles). Pour dirty water through and time how long it takes. Observe clarity.
  3. Design filter 2 - High clarity: Build a filter using multiple coffee filters. Pour dirty water through and time it. Observe clarity.
  4. Design filter 3 - Balanced: Build a filter with layers (gravel, sand, coffee filter). Test flow rate and clarity.
  5. Measure flow rate: Time how long it takes for 1/2 cup of water to pass through each filter. Record times.
  6. Measure clarity: Compare the filtered water from each design. Rank them from clearest to least clear (visual inspection).
  7. Analyze tradeoffs: Create a graph or chart showing flow rate vs clarity for each design. Which design is best? It depends on the goal!
  8. Discuss: What is a tradeoff? When would you want fast flow? When would you want high clarity? How do engineers make these decisions?

Materials you need

  • Coffee Filters
  • Washed Play Sand
  • Gravel (mixed size)
  • Distilled Water
    Core solvent/control variable.
  • All-Purpose Flour
  • Clear Plastic Bottles (1–2L)
    Can be donated/collected.
  • Clear Plastic Cups (9–12 oz)

Big ideas

  • Separation & Filtration
  • Systems & Models
  • Variables & Fair Tests

Topic areas this project explores

  • Engineering Design
    Defining problems, designing solutions, testing prototypes, optimizing designs, and the iterative engineering process.
  • Matter and Its Interactions
    Structure and properties of matter, chemical reactions, conservation of mass, and how substances interact at the molecular level.

Download as PDF

Save this project to print or use offline.

Share this project