Filtration Flow Rate vs Clarity
Engineer filters balancing flow speed against water clarity; introduce tradeoff thinking.
40 minMess: 3/5Engineering DesignMatter & Interactions
Safety notes
No ingestion. Wash hands after.
Step-by-step instructions
- Prepare dirty water: Mix flour with distilled water to create cloudy 'dirty water' in a clear cup.
- Design filter 1 - Fast flow: Build a filter using only gravel (large particles). Pour dirty water through and time how long it takes. Observe clarity.
- Design filter 2 - High clarity: Build a filter using multiple coffee filters. Pour dirty water through and time it. Observe clarity.
- Design filter 3 - Balanced: Build a filter with layers (gravel, sand, coffee filter). Test flow rate and clarity.
- Measure flow rate: Time how long it takes for 1/2 cup of water to pass through each filter. Record times.
- Measure clarity: Compare the filtered water from each design. Rank them from clearest to least clear (visual inspection).
- Analyze tradeoffs: Create a graph or chart showing flow rate vs clarity for each design. Which design is best? It depends on the goal!
- Discuss: What is a tradeoff? When would you want fast flow? When would you want high clarity? How do engineers make these decisions?
Materials you need
- Coffee Filters
- Washed Play Sand
- Gravel (mixed size)
- Distilled WaterCore solvent/control variable.
- All-Purpose Flour
- Clear Plastic Bottles (1–2L)Can be donated/collected.
- Clear Plastic Cups (9–12 oz)
Big ideas
- Separation & Filtration
- Systems & Models
- Variables & Fair Tests
Topic areas this project explores
- Engineering DesignDefining problems, designing solutions, testing prototypes, optimizing designs, and the iterative engineering process.
- Matter and Its InteractionsStructure and properties of matter, chemical reactions, conservation of mass, and how substances interact at the molecular level.